If you want to see cryptozoology at its best pay a visit to Marc van Roosmalen's
website. The sheer number of new species he discovered in the last ten years by following local traditions and using the help of native hunters is simply staggering.
Why am I suspicious of the Indian case? Cryptozoology has suffered for several decades of what I call the
Gigantopithecus syndrome. If you are familiar with Grover Krantz and his work you'll know that pretty much every single "giant hominid" tradition as been explained away by using the
Gigantopithecus. Too bad that all of our knowledge of this large primate stems from a few hundreds separate teeth and a handful of incomplete jaws. We have no postcranial bones so we have absolutely no idea of how it looked like. Grover Krantz strongly pushed the bipedal theory, mainly to easily explain Bigfot and friends using a single known species. After Krantz died the
Gigantopithecus theory began to lose ground. This primate is now seen as an oversized, terrestrial and
quadrupedal orang-utan, most likely covering the same ecological niche as Africa's gorillas. A very poor Bigfoot candidate. Also Krantz's work has been often questioned: there are even some who accused him of having "embellished" truth a little to accomodate his own theories. The
Gigantopithecus party is still alive and well though, especially in the United States and Asia and they are not going down without a fight. First we had the Malayan case, now this... right in the middle of what is considered as the
Gigantopithecus range.
Also the footprint is quite suspicious: this beast is supposed to be well over 600 pounds and strongly built. I am no heavyweight boxing champion, but I leave much deeper footprints in mud.
May I also remember that even the remotest corners of Asia are not immune to putting up shows for tourists: the celebrated "Lake Van Monster", which even made it to the CNN, has been shown to be an hoax by the local council (or whatever is the equivalent in Turkey), eager to emulate the Loch Ness success (no offense meant). The Chinese went one step further and the Shennonjia (I hope I got it right) Park Authority has offered generous cash rewards for pictures, film footages, hair samples etc proving the existence of the Ye-Ren or Wildman. Wouldn't be too surprised if our Indian friends would try the same.